Partisan Politics Trumps Ethical Science:
Passage of House Bill Unnecessary, Undesirable, and Unethical
January 11, 2007 — Chicago, Illinois
— In response to passage of H.R 3, The Stem Cell Research
Enhancement Act of 2007, Director of The Center for Bioethics &
Human Dignity (CBHD) C. Ben Mitchell, Ph.D., states “Partisan
politics has trumped ethical science. Not only is it unethical to
kill embryos for their stem cells, it is unnecessary and
undesirable.”
The Stem Cell Research Enhancement Act of
2007, which is virtually identical to a bill vetoed by President
Bush last year, allows the use of Federal taxpayer dollars to
support and thereby encourage the destruction of nascent human life
for highly speculative research purposes.
In contrast, non-embryonic stem cells are
being used to treat six-dozen diseases and conditions in human
patients. Just this week the world received news that cells from
amniotic fluid possess all of the desirable traits of embryonic stem
cells but not the undesirable traits such as the proclivity for
tumor formation that embryonic stem cells exhibit.
According to Mitchell, “This study should
have put an immediate stop to the pro-embryo-destructive stem cell
bill.”
It is now evident that many of the
byproducts of live birth—amniotic fluid, placenta, and umbilical
cord blood—contain stem cells that may rival embryonic stem cells in
their flexibility and usefulness.
True human flourishing is not a product of
the destruction of the youngest members of our human family. “Only
through political sleight of hand may someone argue that human
embryos are not human lives,” says Mitchell, “for they are both
human and alive.”
While the need for relief of human suffering
is great, we must not seek cures for some at the expense of the
lives of others.CBHD
About The Center for Bioethics & Human
Dignity
The Center for Bioethics & Human Dignity is
a 501 (c)(3) non-profit organization dedicated to exploring the
nexus of biomedicine, biotechnology, and our common humanity. The
Center exists to equip thought leaders to engage the issues of
bioethics using the tools of rigorous research, conceptual analysis,
charitable critique, leading-edge publication, and effective
teaching.
Contact:
For Interviews with Center Director C. Ben Mitchell, Ph.D., or
Other Center Personnel
Danielle Morrow 847-345-7248 or
media@cbhd.org
|