There is significant discussion about the ethical use of assisted reproductive technologies (ART) in fields of bioethics, theology, philosophy, and medicine. Religious groups have also addressed the appropriate uses and limits of ART for their adherents, and many have developed formal statements intended to direct adherents’ behavior in this regard. However, many couples dealing with infertility are either unaware of or do not make use of such discussions and guidelines. Indeed, print and on-line materials directed at individuals seeking ART tend to focus primarily on technical information about diagnosis and treatment, and on providing emotional support through what is invariably a difficult journey. The research uses in-depth personal interviews with Christian couples dealing with infertility to explore how faith plays a role on their decision-making about these issues. Preliminary results suggest that personal faith is a very important factor, but that couples are reluctant to share with and find few tangible resources from their faith communities. A long-term goal is to develop practical resources for church groups that wish to provide meaningful support to couples dealing with infertility decisions.